Ability and disability, as Collins says, is seen based on how learners interact with different activities in the classroom. Ability is what the students can do and disability is what the children are seemingly
unable to do on the first few attempts. By positioning students in certain environments can teachers
tell where weaknesses lie. However, by not providing enough avenues for expression can students of
different backgrounds and prior knowledge can hinder the debut of their abilities. This can then be seen
as disability.
A disability is a wall on different pathways of the brain. It can create blocks that make it more difficult
for someone with a disability to achieve literacy or understanding. However, that does not mean that
someone with a disability cannot achieve literacy or understanding of the world. It means that they, and
educators, have to think of more creative ways to get around the “wall”.
The way we currently teach literacy is not particularly helpful for those who need helping climbing over
the wall because literacy is taught linearly and cumulatively as a lesson to be learned and not necessary
as a skill to be acquired. Linearly means simply that you learn one skills about literacy in order to attain
the next based on what an instructor has showed you. The cumulative nature implies that a learner has to
understand the former before moving onto the latter. However, with a wall in place in the mind of a
student with disabilities, they need other methods to understand literacy. The difference between
acquiring skills and learning lessons is that acquisition is much more involved with retaining useful
information in a practical, skills-based experience. Meanwhile, learning is more involved with traditional
forms of instruction of straight retention and regurgitation of information in an abstract format. This is
what Paul Gee says in “A strange fact about not learning to read.” In addition, as Kluth &
Olcott-Chandler say, we have to presume competence within our students. We, as educators have to
believe that even those who present with disabilities are capable of acquiring skills. Competence in
literacy is difficult to acquire, particularly for young learner who already have many difficulties, whether
they are identified with disabilities or not. Already from this course, what I’ve noticed is an emphasis
made on multiple means of expression and engagement. As educators, it create equity in the classroom,
we must constantly learn and understand that there is more to literacy than what a student can write,
read, or say to others. It is most important for them to strengthen those skill sets, but also to allow for
learners to give what they can, as unique as it may be.
Readings:
Kluth & Olcott-Chandler (2007), Chapter 2
Lupiani-Farrell, M. & Matthews, F.M. (2010). Ready to Read: A Multisensory Approach
to Language
Collins (2011)
Gee (2014) Chapter 1: “A strange fact about not learning to read” from Situated
Language and Learning, pp.6-17
References
Images:
https://en.unesco.org/sites/default/files/styles/img_688x358/public/infocus_ild2015_drupal.jpg?itok=_vXkr_W9
Images:
https://en.unesco.org/sites/default/files/styles/img_688x358/public/infocus_ild2015_drupal.jpg?itok=_vXkr_W9
Readings:
Kluth & Olcott-Chandler (2007), Chapter 2
Lupiani-Farrell, M. & Matthews, F.M. (2010). Ready to Read: A Multisensory Approach
to Language
Collins (2011)
Gee (2014) Chapter 1: “A strange fact about not learning to read” from Situated
Language and Learning, pp.6-17

No comments:
Post a Comment